Updated November 2026. Which renovations can lower what your home is worth, and which simply cost more than they return. Cost vs. Value, Fannie Mae and NAR figures below are dated in the text.
Renovations that can decrease home value are those that remove something buyers filter for, like a bedroom or garage, or that lack required permits. Others just lose money: as of November 2026, the latest Cost vs. Value report we could read (2025) shows an upscale primary suite addition recouping only 18% of its $351,613 cost.
Jump to: 📍 The list · 💲 Lower value or low return · 🏠 Bedrooms and garages · 🪜 Pools · 🤝 Before you build · ❓ FAQ
Key takeaways
- Recouping less than 100% doesn’t mean your home lost value. It means you spent more than buyers will pay back.
- Bedroom count and garage spaces are search filters on the home search sites, so removing one can hide your home from buyers.
- Fannie Mae tells appraisers to comment on additions built without a required permit.
- Realtors’ top pre-sale advice in NAR’s 2025 report was plain: paint the whole home (50%).
Our sibling guide on renovation mistakes when selling covers the process errors. This page is the project list: seven jobs to think twice about, with the number behind each one where a number exists.
What renovations decrease home value?
These seven come up most. The first three can pull the value down. The rest usually add some value but return far less than they cost.
| Renovation | What goes wrong | Evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Combining two bedrooms into one | Drops you out of “3+ bedroom” searches | Our guidance; no national figure |
| Converting the garage | Removes parking and storage on streets that expect both | Our guidance; varies by area |
| Work without a required permit | Can slow the loan and invite a price cut | Fannie Mae B4-1.3-05 |
| Upscale primary suite addition | $351,613 cost, $63,136 resale value | 18% recouped, 2025 |
| Upscale major kitchen | $164,104 cost, $58,561 resale value | 36% recouped, 2025 |
| Upscale bath remodel | $81,612 cost, $34,000 resale value | 42% recouped, 2025 |
| Very personal finishes | Buyers price in the cost of redoing them | Our guidance |
Dollar figures are national averages from the 2025 Cost vs. Value report. We looked for a 2026 edition on the same site and didn’t find one, so use these as a guide. Your market can be quite different.
Is a low return the same as losing value?
No, and mixing the two up leads to bad decisions. Take the upscale kitchen. It cost $164,104 and added about $58,561. Your home is worth more afterward. You just paid about $105,500 more than a buyer would hand back. That’s fine if you’ll live with that kitchen for 10 years. It’s a poor plan if you’re listing next spring.
Real value loss is rarer. It happens when a project takes away what buyers want or leaves a problem behind. A home with one bedroom fewer than the street’s norm competes in a smaller pool. A home with an unpermitted addition can run into trouble at the appraisal. Our guide to selling a house with unpermitted work covers disclosure and your three options.
Smaller jobs tend to look better. In the same 2025 table, a garage door replacement recouped 268% and a steel entry door 216%, while a midrange bath remodel came back at 80%. Whether a full kitchen makes sense is its own question; see is a kitchen renovation worth it before selling.
Does removing a bedroom or converting a garage hurt value?
It can, and it depends on what’s normal nearby. Buyers set filters for beds, baths and parking before they look at a single photo. So do their agents when they search the MLS. When you list with Beycome, you enter those same details in the questionnaire, and that data decides who sees your home. Change the count, and you change the audience.
Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide says improvements should conform to the neighborhood in age, type, design and materials. When buyers resist a home because it doesn’t fit its area, for reasons including design, size or condition, the appraiser must address the effect on value and marketability. A garage turned into a gym on a street of two-car garages is the kind of thing that can draw that comment.
If you’ve already done it, you have options. A converted garage with a permit, heat, cooling and a 7-foot ceiling may count as living space; our guide to what counts as square footage walks through the rules. Keep the permit paperwork, and show how a buyer could use the room.
What about skipped permits?
Fannie Mae’s guide says an appraiser who finds an addition without a required permit must comment on the quality and appearance of the work and its effect, if any, on value. That comment can slow a loan. Buyers may ask for a lower price or a permit before closing.
Ask your building department about an after-the-fact permit well before you list, since opening a wall for an inspector can take weeks. Watch your contractor too: the FTC lists a contractor who asks you to get the permits among the signs of a scam. Our guide on planning a building project shows where permits fit.
Sell smarter
List your home on the MLS from $99
A flat fee instead of a percentage, and $0 to Beycome at closing. You stay in control of your sale.
Sell your home →Buy smarter
Get up to 2% back at closing
On homes listed by other agents, Beycome credits you up to 2% of the price at closing (1% kept, $1,499 minimum; not on FSBO homes or homes listed by Beycome sellers).
Buy a home →Does a swimming pool lower home value?
Rarely outright, but we can’t give you an honest national number. The estimates we found vary widely and mostly come from companies with something to sell, so we’re not quoting them. Think local. In a warm area where most homes have one, a pool can be expected. On a northern street with none, some buyers will see upkeep and insurance, not value. Check recent sales nearby with and without one before you spend.
How do you avoid over-improving before you sell?
Run this check before you sign with a contractor:
- Pull 12 months of sales on your street with our CMA property value calculator.
- Add the project’s real cost to your home’s likely value today.
- If the total passes the highest nearby sale, assume you won’t get it all back.
- Ask whether the project removes a bedroom, a bath or parking. If so, price the lost buyers in.
- Confirm the permit before work starts, in writing.
Then consider the cheaper jobs. In NAR’s 2025 Remodeling Impact Report, Realtors most often advised painting the entire home (50%), painting one room (41%) and new roofing (37%). Nothing fancy there. For the U.S. picture, NAR put the median existing-home price at $417,500 in September 2026, but your street’s range is the one that counts. Our renovation checklist and our guide to what to do during and after a renovation help if you go ahead.
Materials matter on the small jobs too. Cheap finishes show wear fast at showings, and durable, strong materials feel safer to a buyer walking through. While the work is underway, storage solutions for renovations keep furniture out of the dust.
Already renovated, and ready to sell? A Beycome listing puts your home on the major home search sites and the MLS, from $99 in most states ($129 in California and Illinois), with $0 due to Beycome at closing. State disclosure forms are in your dashboard under Legal Forms, which helps if you have permit history to explain. Want an expert with you on pricing an unusual home? Concierge is $1,399, and every decision stays yours.
Questions about renovations and home value
What home improvements add the least value?
On 2025 national averages, upscale primary suite additions recouped 18%, midrange primary suite additions 32% and upscale major kitchens 36% of their cost.
Does removing a bedroom lower home value?
It can, especially where the street’s norm has more bedrooms than yours would. Buyers filter by bedroom count. Check nearby sales first.
Does converting a garage decrease home value?
It can where buyers expect parking. A permitted, heated and cooled conversion usually holds up better than a bare slab with a garage door still on it.
Can bad renovations hurt an appraisal?
Yes. Fannie Mae’s guide says improvements should conform to the neighborhood, and appraisers must address market resistance and comment on additions without required permits.
Is it better to sell as is or renovate first?
It depends on the job. Paint and small repairs often pay back. Big remodels rarely do on a short timeline, so compare the cost with nearby sales.
Do I have to disclose unpermitted work?
Disclosure rules vary by state, and most expect you to share what you know about the home’s condition. Ask a local real estate attorney about your form.
Costs and resale values: 2025 Cost vs. Value report, national averages; figures read November 7, 2026. Bedroom, garage, pool and finish notes are Beycome’s guidance, not measured data. Appraisal rules: Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.3-05 (June 4, 2025). Permit and disclosure rules vary by state and city. General information, not legal or appraisal advice.
Beycome prices as of November 2026: Basic from $99 in most states ($129 in California and Illinois); Concierge $1,399. “$0 at closing” means no Beycome fee at closing; other closing costs still apply.
Sources
- Remodeling 2025 Cost vs. Value report (JLC), read November 7, 2026.
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide, B4-1.3-05, Improvements Section of the Appraisal Report, read November 7, 2026.
- NAR, 2025 Remodeling Impact Report release (April 9, 2025), read November 7, 2026.
- NAR, Existing-Home Sales, September 2026, read November 7, 2026.
- FTC, How To Avoid a Home Improvement Scam, read November 7, 2026.
- Beycome, listing package features, November 2026.
Disclosure & Disclaimer
Beycome provides real estate services through affiliated licensed brokerages and has a commercial interest in the services and business models discussed on this blog. Content reflects Beycome’s perspective and may promote our services; it should not be treated as independent or neutral reporting.
Articles are provided for general informational and educational purposes only, not as financial, tax, legal, or investment advice or a recommendation for your particular situation. Reading this blog does not create a brokerage, advisory, or other professional relationship.
Information, opinions, pricing, service descriptions, and comparisons reflect the sources and information available when an article was published or last updated and may change. Although we aim for accuracy, we do not guarantee that all content is complete, current, or applicable to your circumstances. Laws, market conditions, and service availability vary by location. Examples and estimated savings are illustrative, depend on stated assumptions, and do not guarantee individual results.
Verify relevant information directly and consult qualified professionals before making decisions. Beycome services are subject to applicable agreements, eligibility requirements, and state-specific terms.
