Updated October 2026. A step-by-step tenant screening process for small landlords, with the federal rules that apply.
Tenant screening means checking an applicant’s identity, income, credit, rental history and, where allowed, criminal history before you sign a lease. Do it the same way for everyone, with written criteria. As of October 2026, two federal laws shape it: the Fair Housing Act bars discrimination on 7 protected traits, and the Fair Credit Reporting Act requires a notice if a report leads you to say no.
Jump to: 🏠 Why screen · 📍 Legal rules · 🪜 Steps · 🤝 Deciding · ❓ FAQ
Key takeaways
- The Fair Housing Act protects race, color, religion, sex, handicap (disability), familial status and national origin. Many states and cities add more.
- If you deny an applicant, raise the deposit or add terms based on a screening report, the FCRA requires an adverse action notice.
- A tenant screening report can include credit, evictions and lawsuits, employment, criminal history and a risk score, per the CFPB.
- Write your criteria down before you advertise, and apply them the same way to every applicant.
Your rental is a major asset. A careful, fair screening process protects it and keeps you on the right side of the law. Screening is one of six real estate management tips we cover for small landlords. Here’s a process a small landlord can run without a property manager.
Why should landlords screen tenants?
Screening shows you how an applicant has handled rent, credit and past leases, the core of what makes a good tenant. Applicants with a broken lease on their record often settle the balance and explain it upfront, so read the whole file. That’s the best predictor you have of how they’ll treat yours. Skipping it can lead to:
- Damage to the property beyond normal wear.
- Late or missed rent payments.
- Unpaid utility bills in your name.
- Legal costs and months of lost rent if you have to evict.
Turnover is costly too. TransUnion SmartMove’s list of rental Statistics says 54% of apartments turn over every year. Every move-out means cleaning, repairs and empty weeks, so finding a tenant who stays is worth the effort. It also costs less than real estate debt recovery from a tenant who skipped later.
What laws apply to tenant screening?
Fair Housing Act
Under 42 U.S.C. 3604, it’s unlawful to refuse to rent, or to set different terms, because of race, color, religion, sex, handicap, familial status or national origin. That also covers ads: you can’t publish a listing that shows a preference based on those traits. Some small owner-occupied rentals have narrow exemptions, but the ad rule still applies. State and local laws often add protections, such as source of income.
Fair Credit Reporting Act
If you take “adverse action” based on a consumer report, 15 U.S.C. 1681m says you must tell the applicant. Adverse action includes denying the application, asking for a bigger deposit or a co-signer, or charging more rent. The notice must name the company that supplied the report, say that company didn’t make the decision, and explain the applicant’s right to a free copy within 60 days and to dispute errors. If you used a credit score, disclose it.
What a screening report contains
The CFPB lists what a tenant screening report may include: credit reports, rental history including evictions and lawsuits, employment verification, criminal history, sex offender registries, a national terrorist watchlist, and a risk score based on criteria the landlord picks. The CFPB also warns that wrong or outdated data can hurt applicants, which is one more reason to give them a chance to explain.
How do you screen potential tenants, step by step?
1. Write your criteria first
Before you advertise, decide what you require: a minimum income (often stated as a multiple of rent), a credit standard, no recent evictions, a pet policy, a maximum number of occupants allowed by local code. Put it in writing and share it with every applicant. This is your best defense against a discrimination claim.
2. Take a full application
Ask every applicant for the same information: full name, past addresses for several years, employer and income, references and written permission to run a screening report. Charge the same fee to everyone, within any limit your state sets.
3. Confirm identity
Check a government photo ID against the application. Make sure the name, date of birth and past addresses match what the screening report returns. Many landlords run screening inside their rental software; here’s what features to compare when choosing property management software.
4. Run credit and background reports
Use a screening service that follows the FCRA. Look at payment patterns and debts, not just the score. Use criminal history carefully and only where state and local law allow; a blanket ban on anyone with any record can create fair housing risk.
5. Verify income and employment
Ask for recent pay stubs, offer letters or tax returns, and call the employer using a number you find yourself, not one the applicant gives you. Confirm the start date and pay.
6. Call past landlords
Previous landlords can tell you if rent came on time, if the unit was left in good shape and if neighbors complained. Try to reach the landlord before the current one, who may be less biased.
Sell smarter
List your home on the MLS from $99
A flat fee instead of a percentage, and $0 to Beycome at closing. You stay in control of your sale.
Sell your home →Buy smarter
Get up to 2% back at closing
On homes listed by other agents, Beycome credits you up to 2% of the price at closing (1% kept, $1,499 minimum; not on FSBO homes or homes listed by Beycome sellers).
Buy a home →7. Check references and meet in person
Personal references add color but carry less weight than records. A short meeting or showing helps you explain house rules and answer questions. Ask the same questions of everyone, and keep notes.
How do you decide, and what if you say no?
Compare each applicant to your written criteria, in the order applications arrived. If someone meets them, approve. If you deny or change terms because of the report, send the adverse action notice. Keep applications, reports and notes for a few years in case questions come up later.
Watch for warning signs: gaps the applicant won’t explain, documents that don’t match, pressure to skip steps or pay cash for a fast move-in. Any of them is a reason to slow down, not to guess. For more depth, see our guide to real estate background checks and how to know your home’s next tenant and our page on credit score issues when buying or renting.
What else should landlords set up before move-in?
Use a written lease that follows your state’s rules on deposits, notice and entry. Do a move-in inspection with dated photos, and give the tenant a copy. Make the home secure: our tips on making sure your windows keep the unwanted out are a good start. Florida owners should read our summary of Florida landlords’ rights and duties, and anyone with several units can use our tips on how landlords manage rental properties.
Renters reading this can learn what landlords look for in things to keep in mind before renting for the first time.
Buying or selling a rental property?
If you’re adding a rental, read seven things to keep in mind if you’re looking to invest in real estate and how to rent out your first home when you buy a second. The Beycome buyer program has no upfront fee: Beycome keeps 1% of the price (minimum $1,499) and credits the rest of the buyer-agent commission at closing, with lender approval. It’s open to every buyer on homes listed by other agents; the credit can’t apply where no buyer-agent commission is offered, like most FSBO homes, or on homes listed by Beycome sellers.
Ready to sell a rental instead? Beycome lists homes on the MLS with a flat fee MLS listing from $99, with $0 due to Beycome at closing. If the home is occupied, check your lease and state law on notice for showings first.
Frequently asked questions
What is real estate pre-screening for tenants?
A first check, often a short questionnaire, against your written criteria before a full application and report. Ask every prospect the same questions.
What does a tenant screening report include?
Per the CFPB, it can include credit, rental history and evictions, employment, criminal history, sex offender registries and a risk score.
Do I have to tell an applicant why I denied them?
If the decision was based on a screening report, yes. The FCRA requires an adverse action notice naming the reporting company and the applicant’s rights.
What can’t a landlord screen for?
Race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status or national origin under federal law, plus any traits your state or city protects.
Can I run a credit check without permission?
Get written authorization on the application. Screening services generally require it before they’ll pull a report.
How long does tenant screening take?
Online reports can come back quickly. Calls to employers and past landlords are what take time, so plan for a few days in total.
Federal rules as read October 27, 2026; state and local laws add rules on fees, criminal history and protected traits. Beycome prices as of November 2026: Basic $99 ($129 in California and Illinois). “$0 at closing” means no Beycome fee at closing; taxes, title and any agreed buyer-agent compensation still apply. Buyer credit: minimum $1,499, lender approval, not on FSBO homes or homes listed by Beycome sellers. Beycome lists in 17 states and DC. General information, not legal advice.
Sources
- 42 U.S.C. 3604, Fair Housing Act, read October 27, 2026.
- 15 U.S.C. 1681m, FCRA adverse action duties, read October 27, 2026.
- CFPB, what is a tenant screening report, read October 27, 2026.
- TransUnion SmartMove, 26 renting statistics, read October 27, 2026.
- Beycome, listing package features, October 2026.
Disclosure & Disclaimer
Beycome provides real estate services through affiliated licensed brokerages and has a commercial interest in the services and business models discussed on this blog. Content reflects Beycome’s perspective and may promote our services; it should not be treated as independent or neutral reporting.
Articles are provided for general informational and educational purposes only, not as financial, tax, legal, or investment advice or a recommendation for your particular situation. Reading this blog does not create a brokerage, advisory, or other professional relationship.
Information, opinions, pricing, service descriptions, and comparisons reflect the sources and information available when an article was published or last updated and may change. Although we aim for accuracy, we do not guarantee that all content is complete, current, or applicable to your circumstances. Laws, market conditions, and service availability vary by location. Examples and estimated savings are illustrative, depend on stated assumptions, and do not guarantee individual results.
Verify relevant information directly and consult qualified professionals before making decisions. Beycome services are subject to applicable agreements, eligibility requirements, and state-specific terms.
